Null

English | Spanish | Dutch
Log in

On the pointlessness of machine learning based time delayed prediction of TBM operational data

    Tim Altman
    By Tim Altman Replies (1)

    Interesting article. You can read the full article, as it has been released by the authors and Elsevier under Creative Commons CC-BY license, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

    Authors:

    Georg H.Erharter and ThomasMarcher

    Graz University of Technology – Institute of Rock Mechanics and Tunnelling, Rechbauerstraße 12, Graz, Austria

    Received 7 October 2019, Revised 18 August 2020, Accepted 6 September 2020, Available online 5 November 2020 on Elsevier publication 'Automation in Construction'.

    Highlights

    Forecasts of TBM operational data based on time delayed prediction is pointless.

    One step ahead predictions cannot contain valuable information for TBM tunneling.

    Heterogeneous TBM data point spacing poses a challenge for machine learning.

    Special accuracy measures and close up plots are needed for forecast evaluation.

     

    Abstract

    In tunneling, predictions of the rockmass conditions ahead of the face are of great interest to be able to take appropriate countermeasures at the right time. Besides investigations like drilling or geophysics, new approaches in mechanized tunneling aim at forecasting the geology ahead via Machine Learning models. These models are trained to forecast tunnel boring machine data by learning from recorded data in already excavated parts of the tunnel. Simply judging from high accuracies, these results may look promising at the first sight, but forecasts like this are mostly just delayed and slightly altered versions of the input data and no predictive value can result from them. This paper shows deficits in the current practice of data driven forecasts ahead of the tunnel face and raises impetus for further research in this particular field and TBM data analysis in general.

     

    To read the article (all information above has been taken from the link below with the above mentioned license)

    https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0926580520310232

     

     

     

     

     

    image

    image